Best Materials for Bike Frames
The best material for your bike frame will depend on how you ride, what kind of shape you’re in, where you ride, and what your budget is. Some frames are lighter, heavier, more or less durable, and more or less expensive than others. Here’s a quick comparison of the major types of bike frame materials to help you decide what to buy for yourself. Of course, nothing can compare to trying out a bike on your own, so be sure to give several different materials a try when you go shopping. You might be surprised.
You’ll hear a lot of things about various materials. Most of them are false, to some degree. Some may be over generalizations. Others are out of date. So, think before you believe it when someone else tells you that getting an aluminum bike frame means a harsh ride, that a steel frame gives you a nice ride quality but the metal softens with age, or that titanium means a soft, whippy frame. There’s a lot of conventional bike frame wisdom that’s either a distortion of the real thing, or pure fiction. You can make a good bike out of any kind of material, and an equally bad bike out of all materials. The construction and methods used make a big difference, as does your riding style.
Three Big Factors
The three big factors to pay attention to when picking a frame material are weight, strength, and stiffness. Many people confuse stiffness with strength. However, titanium is just as strong as steel, even if it’s a lot less stiff by weight. Different materials flex to a different degree under the same amount of force. Stiffness affects how the bike frame feels to ride. Strength affects its durability, but not the quality of the ride. Weight can affect the amount of effort you need to put into riding. Remember that each material has the same weight for a given quantity of it. If you see a bike claiming to be lighter than other bikes of the same material, it’s just using less steel, aluminum, or other frame material.
Steel is the traditional material. It tends to be strong but heavy. Well made steel bikes can mitigate the weight somewhat, by using thinner tubes. Comparatively, aluminum is much lighter, but about third as stiff and half as strong. This is why you’ll usually see thicker walls and larger tubing in aluminum bikes. Titanium is about the same strength as steel, weighs about half as much and is half as stiff. Slightly larger diameters are used to prevent whippiness in titanium bike frames. Titanium tends to be very expensive.
Carbon Fiber
Another, non-metal, material that’s getting a lot of attention lately is carbon fiber. It has a much more pronounced appearance of grain than metal. If these fibers are well aligned, this is actually a helpful feature, because it can provide more strength where your bike receives more stress. Unfortunately, this technology is still somewhat experimental, which means that manufacturers don’t always know how to get the most out of it. Fiber frames are often not as durable as other materials, and can be weak where metal fittings are attached. This material is expensive, but also doesn’t corrode and is quite light.
Tags: bicycle, bike, bike frames, carbon fiber bike frame, cycling, titanium bike frameFebruary 09 2008 | bikes | 5 Comments »